Who is Red John?
EN - FR

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Reede Smith
Reede Smith

LATEST THEORIES

Hi guys! :)
 
Looking back, I appreciate everyone's theories, no matter how crazy they sounded, at least they have thought about the show and gave it some thought! 

I still think the Partridge theories were the best, I think the writers and Bruno Heller made a huge mistake when they didn't even consider him to be RJ..My heart always said Partridge was the killer.

But anyway, well done to everyone who has come up with theories, you guys gave it more thought than the people who worked on the show! 

Which episodes did you guys like the best? I liked the one with crazy Rebecca killing Bosco and his team,  and the one with the blinking red light. ( James Panzer). And also every episode with Bret Stiles in it! :) What about you?

Have a lovely week! :)










Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I figured we can get some more cool theories goin on this site. I'll start with something most don't seem to think about. When it came to using the voice as a clue to who Red John was, it should have been obvious that it was a terrible thing to focus on. Which was why McAllister used the voice at the church scene. It was Heller's way of giving everyone who used the voice as a clue the big middle finger. So many of us focused so much on that and were SO sure that Partridge was the culprit. Anyways, what I wanted to say about the whole "voice as a clue thing", is that there was, in fact, a second voice that most of us forgot about. Remember when they went to Mexico to try and save Renfrew before RJ got there but they failed? And we all focused on the "He is Mar" messege attempt. At the very end of that episode, that prostitute's cell phone ringed and Jane answered it listing to someone breathing and then laughing. Listen closely to that voice. Does it sound anything like the high-pitched voice? Or even McAllister's regular voice? To be perfectly honest, it sounded a lot like Minelli. I always found it odd that he suddenly had to go visit his "sick sister in Hawaii". I'm pretty sure he was setting up his trap for Renfrew.Also , on another note, I re-watched the 100th episode and when Jane was asking Minelli about the leads on the RJ case, Minelli began to look suspicious and when Jane asked if there were any suspects he immediately looked away as if something came to mind or some guilt was taking place. I also notice when Minelli looked away, Jane looked at him as if he was observing him.
Just a little something to get this site rolling again. Let me know what you guys think. If you guys are still around.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Like my username states... I AM BORED!!!!  Let's talk something!  Anything! 

So,  like someone suggested I started watching The Killing on Netflix.  HOLY MOTHER OF GOD AND EVERYTHING THAT IS SACRED THIS SHOW IS WHAT PROCEDURAL DRAMA IS ALL ABOUT AND THE MALE/ FEMALE PARTNERSHIP IS COMPLETELY BELIEVABLE, COMPLEX AND ..... HAIR RIPPING FRUSTRATING!  It also stays in the background where it belongs. 

I'm about 3 episodes into season 4 and I can only imagine where and how the writers of The Mentalist got their jobs.  How is it that these cable shows are so spectacular that they are out-doing the BIG GUNS on major networks yet no one hears about them?  Their numbers hardly even exist on the Neilson ratings and I'm lucky if I can find a friend or a co-worker who has even heard of any of these shows. 

I'm trying to decide which I should do... (or do first)

1.  Get new friends
2.  Cut the cable
3.  Get off forums
4.  Stop comparing police dramas to The Mentalist
5.  Send my writers resume to The Mentalist along with everything I think is wrong with the show and sit by the phone.
6.  Go outside and enjoy the last few days of summer because I'm gonna be bitchin' about the cold in a few weeks.

So, what have you guys been doin' all week?  ;)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #18409 • By redjoker23
Show this theory

Tell me what do you think of this!
As odd as
this might seem, Patrick found himself shocked. Red John had finally hit a new
milestone when he predicted in a video the seven names on the list that Jane
wrote.

Lisbon had
just watched the video with and abused Lorelei and with a very convincing
shocked and frustrated face look upon the laptop with the pictures of the seven
suspects… hoping that Patrick will turn himself looking outside that old window
so she could have her little smirk celebrating Jane’s newest fuck-face towards
RJ’s mind games. 

Patrick’s
face and thoughts turn clouded when he saw her little smirk reflected on that
same window glass.

Did she
wanted him to see her smirk or not? It was too late anyways. He already saw it.


He didn’t
wanted to realize what was happening but it was too late.

It took him
seconds to realize the full picture of the moment: Shocking red John statement
by showing how powerful he can be, how above he’s above all us.  And while that terrifying thing was
happening   Lisbon was having a little smirk enjoying
herself while Jane is not looking at her.

Patrick’s
face reflected his thoughts in the same clear way that the glass showed
Lisbon’s smirk. 

Her reaction
to it was all by pleasure.

Lisbon: The
Glass? Really? That’s all that it takes? A glass? So many clues left all along
and you can only tell by the reflection of a window?

Patrick had
that face just-before-crying-when-remembering-her-family.

Patrick:
Teresa?

Lisbon: I
am getting really rusty at this.

Patrick:
No…

Lisbon’s
eyes turn glowy from the upcoming tears.

Lisbon:
It’s so much to remember, so much left to feel, it can not be said on a rooftop
as it mean nothing to me. It does, It really does.

Patrick’s
words were lost.

Lisbon:
“No, you can’t Teresa. It can’t be you.”Hard to say, and even more hard to
think.

Patrick hit
the floor with he’s knees as if a lighting shattered his mind and heart
simultaneously. 

Lisbon look
at him with sort of sadness.  She
regretted slipping away her true color with a silly smirk.

Her true
color was no other but red.

The Red Smirk.

Patrick
tried to take the gun that he kept under the table in case anyone non friendly
ever come around.

It only
took a few seconds for Teresa to realize that he was faking the fall only to
grab the gun. She let him took it and point at her looking all freaked out and
confused.

Lisbon: Don’t
bother. We both know that is not loaded. You don’t use guns unless you really
have to.

Quickly she
rushed to take hers and point him while getting closer.

With the
gun pushing his heart, she moved like a diabolic creature around his limbs
crawling her way until find a pose she liked.

Patrick was
so afraid, so frustrated that let him to feel very badly and violated, sad and
betrayed… and very, very paralyzed.  He
tried to move vaguely to get away from whom was hugging him from behind.
Feeling disgusted try again but she slide the gun from his heart to his
leg. 

-Lisbon: I
need you alive, that includes missing a leg, Patrick.

 -Patrick: Why…? Why did you did this to me?

-Lisbon:
You know it, and you know it very well. You insult me, say fake truths about
me, humiliated me. There was a price to pay. And with time, you did.

-Patrick:
You destroyed my life.

-Lisbon:
You did that on your own. Your arrogance… if only you just take care of your
gift and only your gift. I knew your work back in the days. “Jane: the great
psych”

-Patrick:
You’re beyond crazy.

-Lisbon:  Your talent… oh my… it’s amazing. Almost
impossible. Truly fantastic.  You really
have a gift Patrick. We always have that connection although in the beginning
it was only one way. May way. But still… in the end…. You came back to me.

-Patrick:
What the hell are you talking about?

-Lisbon:
You lost your mind in that asylum remember? Many months happened… for a moment
I felt that I will have to give up on you. It made me think that maybe you were
a bully needing an adult to teach you a lesson.

-Patrick: I
never saw you… before the CBI… OH… oh my… I can’t believe this.

-Lisbon:

The
mentalist’s tears went all the way into Lisbon’s hand which held the gun. She
can feel how his frustration and her temporal feeling of relief melted together
while she told the story of their sick and long relationship.

-Lisbon:  As I told you, I was about to give up on you
but then Sophie called. Finally you were out of the asylum. My games… our games
could continue. Then you did that thing, that crazy thing that remade my plans,
my life. You went to the CBI AND YOU FOUND ME looking for information about red
john.  It was about me. Our connection
was there, you only needed to get rid of your family to see that our connection
was real.

-Lisbon: I
was there to found you and kill you, you insane woman.

-Lisbon:
That’s what you keep telling to yourself. You’re wrong. You only want someone
that is by your side, an equal. Look up to someone and someone looks up to you.
Your opposite on the same weight on the other side of the balance. That’s what
you are for me and me for you.

-Lisbon:
You can’t see it now and i am afraid that you wont be able to see it anymore. I
am your equal and you feel it, I know you do. Over six years together is enough
to know someone. I can tell that you feel something for me. And it’s very
strong. You love me.

-Patrick:
¡IS ONT LOVE YOU FUCKING HORE! ¡I AM GOING TO END YOU!

Lisbon
started pressing on Patrick’s throat with that dark, cold gun.

Lisbon:
Yes, it’s love. All that hate on red john is a mask only. Something that you
put so you won have to deal With your feelings and thoughts, things you want to
do… to be. You need to admit that thanks to me they are gone and now you can
really see that we have a path to do.

-Patrick: ¡No! ¡Never! ¡Dame you! ¡DAME YOU! ¡I AM GOING TO KILL YOU!

Crying,
Patrick look into the sky, the light coming into the room shined on his face
full with tears.

-Lisbon:
Don’t worry love, don’t cry anymore. You want RJ I’ll give it to you. I’ll put
a face and a name so once your pain is gone… you will have time to see that
what left standing after the storm will be me.

-Patrick: ¡RED JOHN! ¡I will kill you before love you!

-Lisbon:  You already do it my love, but you won’t b
able to see it yet. Once the sheriff is gone you will come to me… soon or
later.

 Ya lo haces amor, siempre lo hiciste
pero no podías verlo. Una vez que el sheriff se haya ido, vendrás a mí.

Patrick
started to cry louder and louder.

-Lisbon:
Stand up Patrick.

He had no
more strength to move.

-Lisbon:
You seek my dead but if you know that keep going in a world where I am red John
will only kill you… eventually. I suffer as much as you. I am sorry love,
you’ll see.

Patrick was
lost and afraid, like when you find out that someone watches you while you
sleep. He can not reveal to his worst enemy that he only want to forget the
person he spent most time the last years more then with his own family was the
responsible for all that misery.

He stood
there looking the California Sky.

-Lisbon:  This is the only way that I see you living, at
least for now. Once you’ve killed “your Red John” things will go in a different
way. The last time I did this my mask fell off. ¿Remember? “Tyger Tyger”.

-Patrick:
You sick son of a bitch!!!

-Lisbon:
I’m sorry too Patrick. So much.

Lisbon’s
eyes cried like water running in a river.

-Lisbon:
Close your eyes. Just close them.

-Patrick: I
am going to kill you.

She got
even closer.

-Lisbon:
Just close them love.

She clear
the tears away from his face with her little, smooth and cute fingers.

-Patrick: I
am gonna take your life with my own hands.

-Lisbon:
Ask me if I regret killing your family, ask me cause was a necessary end. But I
do.

-Patrick: I
will shatter you…

-Lisbon:
Ask if I am scared of dying because I am, I do without you. Our connection is
psychic like you… like me. You feel it.  
You are mine and I yours. Remember the times you hugged your dotter,
remember our times in each case driving here, driving there, all the tricks we
put together, your best moments are now, chasing your demons and eventually
finding a resolution with the woman that stand by your side all these
times. 

Red John
didn’t hypnotized people when they could do it to themselves. Someone like Jane
with such and incredible capacity to it and so much need as well was easy to
self suggest.

It didn’t
take him more than seconds to open his eyes looking the glass and see Lisbon
shocked. 

 

After
looking her reaction, he needed some air and went out when end it up sitting on
a bench made of Wood frustrated about this new chapter that started on his
story with Red John.

Seven
names. Seven people.

She
followed him outside. 

Lisbon:
¿How did HE do that?

Patrick:
¿Eh?

Lisbon:
That tape was made two months ago.  Red
Jhon knew the name of the suspects on that list before you did.  I mean… how’s that even possible?

Patrick:
Nah... It’s a Trick.

Lisbon: A
trick how?

Patrick: I
don’t know.

Lisbon’s
phone rings while Patrick looks at the sky getting ready for what is seems to
be a new case.

A new case
in the middle of that crazy moment, he did not wanted to do it but they got
ready to it right away.

Another
case, another red john chase.

Patrick
felt closer than ever but the truth was something he would never achieve.

 

 

 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I just wanna say:
THIS SHOW COULD HAVE BEEN THE BEST TV SHOW EVER IF IT HAD BEEN EXECUTED THE RIGHT WAY. NOT ONLY THEY FUCKED THE REVELATION, BUT GETS WORSE WITH EVERY EPISODE.
THERE IS NO HOPE. 
BRUNO HELLER TRULY GAVE US, THE FAITHFUL MENTALIST FANS, THE FINGER.

PROBABLY GONNA RUIN 'GOTHAM' TOO...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

So does this mean they are gonna explain how Agent Fischer found Jane in Mexico yet Abbot her boss had NO IDEA where Jane was on the island? U would think she would of been the first person he called once he arrived on the island but no. Did he even know she was there ?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The highly-rated police procedural drama series by CBS, "The Mentalist," has been speculated to return to television somewhere in September or October as filming for the upcoming seventh season has already begun, according to reports.Show creator Bruno Heller revealed to The Hollywood Reporter some insights on what to expect in the forthcoming season, which will include a "satisfying conclusion."

"The pleasures of the show rests in the byplay between Robin [Tunney] and Simon [Baker]. Getting rid of Red John allowed us to focus on that human aspect of the show. Red John, as it turns out, was a convenience for Jane because it meant he didn't have to confront the rest of his life and what he's doing," he said.

With regards to the speculations whether fans could hear wedding bells for Simon Baker's Patrick Jane and Robin Tunney's Teresa Lisbon, the executive producer indicated that there will be resolution for those questions.

"After [Red John] goes, for both Lisbon and Jane, there is a palpable sense of 'What now? Do I really want to continue doing the same thing?' It left the two of them without an excuse to decide where that relationship was going. They had always been able to keep it separate. Those questions start bubbling up and the rest of the season was the resolution of those questions," Heller explained.

Meanwhile, Emily Swallow took to her social media to confirm the alleged news of her not returning to season 7.After appearing to 14 episodes in "The Mentalist," Swallow, who plays an FBI agent named Kim Fischer, will leave the team. The site also speculated that there's likely another female character to take Fischer's place in the story.Zap2It, on the other hand, indicated the return of Morena Baccarin as Erica Flynn, a matchmaker who murdered her husband. The character was last seen escaping from prison and later called Jane offering some information in exchange for pardon.

http://www.christianpost.com/news/the-mentalist-season-7-latest-news-wedding-bells-for-patrick-and-t...

Okay, it's over, done.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on